English Setter vs Irish Red and White Setter
Quick answer
These two breeds differ most clearly in 6 recorded ways, set out below. Neither is better. FaunaHub compares what the registries publish and does not pick a winner — which dog suits a household depends on the individual animal and on circumstances no registry records.
Key differences
- English Setter carries the higher published weight figure (36.3 kg against 27.2 kg for the Irish Red and White Setter).
- Published lifespan differs: 12 years for the English Setter, 11-15 years for the Irish Red and White Setter.
- English Setter carries the higher published height figure (68.6 cm against 66 cm for the Irish Red and White Setter).
- Exercise needs: English Setter is recorded in the moderate band, Irish Red and White Setter in the higher band.
- Grooming needs: English Setter is recorded in the moderate band, Irish Red and White Setter in the lower band.
- Shedding: English Setter is recorded in the moderate band, Irish Red and White Setter in the lower band.
Side by side
| Dimension | English Setter | Irish Red and White Setter |
|---|---|---|
| Registry group | Sporting Group | Sporting Group |
| Adult size band | Large | Large |
| Published height |
|
|
| Published weight |
|
|
| Coat length | Medium | Medium |
| Exercise needs | Moderate | Higher |
| Grooming needs | Moderate | Lower |
| Shedding | Moderate | Lower |
| Trainability | Higher | Higher |
| Vocality | Moderate | Moderate |
| Published lifespan | about 12 years | 11–15 years |
Trait rows are three-level bands normalised from a registry's published scale, never scores. “Trainability” describes how readily a breed is said to respond to structured training, not intelligence. “Shedding” is not an allergy signal — no breed is hypoallergenic. A blank means the registry records nothing, which is not the same as the two breeds matching.
Why these two breeds
Each of these breeds is listed as related to the other on the American Kennel Club's own breed pages. FaunaHub compares pairs where that relationship is mutual, so the premise of the comparison comes from the registry rather than from FaunaHub.
Related comparisons
Sources and further reading
Registry entries behind every value on this page. External links open in a new tab. Always confirm specific care decisions with a licensed veterinarian or reputable shelter.
- Breed organizationAmerican Kennel Club — English Setter — Breed Standard & Traits — AKC breed group and recognition tier, published height and weight ranges, life expectancy, coat length and type, and the AKC trait scale bands normalised into FaunaHub ordinal traits. Accessed 2026-09-13.
- Breed organizationAmerican Kennel Club — Irish Red and White Setter — Breed Standard & Traits — AKC breed group and recognition tier, published height and weight ranges, life expectancy, coat length and type, and the AKC trait scale bands normalised into FaunaHub ordinal traits. Accessed 2026-09-13.
- VeterinaryAVMA — Pet Owner Resources — American Veterinary Medical Association pet-care hub
Last updated: